2014 Magic Conspiracy
Card values, the most valuable cards, and a free AI grade estimate for the copy in your hand. Released June 6, 2014.
Scan it free. The app identifies the card, estimates its grade, and tells you whether it is worth sending to PSA or Beckett.
Most valuable 2014 Magic Conspiracy cards
| # | Card | Rarity | Market |
|---|---|---|---|
| 36 | Treasonous OgreFoil | Uncommon | $106 |
| 102 | MisdirectionFoil | Rare | $76.91 |
| 191 | Pernicious DeedFoil | Mythic | $68.41 |
| 120 | Phage the UntouchableFoil | Mythic | $65.91 |
| 164 | ExplorationFoil | Rare | $58.95 |
| 42 | Dack FaydenFoil | Mythic | $57.89 |
| 169 | Hydra OmnivoreFoil | Mythic | $44.32 |
| 49 | Marchesa, the Black RoseFoil | Mythic | $38.17 |
| 204 | Silent ArbiterFoil | Rare | $36.22 |
| 184 | Basandra, Battle SeraphFoil | Rare | $36.01 |
| 206 | Vedalken OrreryFoil | Rare | $30.50 |
| 210 | Reflecting PoolFoil | Rare | $25.29 |
| 188 | Fires of YavimayaFoil | Uncommon | $22.25 |
| 23 | Muzzio, Visionary ArchitectFoil | Mythic | $22.05 |
| 108 | StifleFoil | Rare | $21.89 |
| 196 | Altar of DementiaFoil | Rare | $21.42 |
| 147 | Mana GeyserFoil | Common | $18.65 |
| 56 | Coercive PortalFoil | Mythic | $16.00 |
| 85 | Unquestioned AuthorityFoil | Uncommon | $15.83 |
| 187 | Edric, Spymaster of TrestFoil | Rare | $14.24 |
| 41 | Brago, King EternalFoil | Rare | $12.96 |
| 35 | Scourge of the ThroneFoil | Mythic | $12.67 |
| 84 | Swords to PlowsharesFoil | Uncommon | $12.29 |
| 183 | Wrap in VigorFoil | Common | $12.18 |
| 189 | Mirari's WakeFoil | Mythic | $12.00 |
TCGplayer prices via Scryfall, updated September 10, 2026. Raw, ungraded, the highest-priced finish of each card. A market price, not a sale.
Is it worth grading?
11 cards in 2014 Magic Conspiracy list at $30 or more raw on TCGplayer. Grading at PSA runs about $25 to $30 a card once shipping and insurance both ways are counted, so those 11 are the cards where a high grade can pay for itself. For the rest, a grade usually costs more than it adds.
The deciding question is condition, and that is what the scanner reads: photograph the front and back and The Hobby Treasury scores centering, corners, edges and surface, gives a PSA-style estimate, and makes the worth-submitting call before you pay a fee.
What the scanner checks on your copy
The grade is an AI estimate to help you decide, never an official grade. The app also flags reprint and counterfeit red flags.
2014 Magic Conspiracy checklist
Showing the 175 most valuable of the 210 cards in the set.
Free unlimited scanning. Save your collection, grades and values with a Treasury Membership.