THE HOBBY 2016 Magic Shadows over Innistrad
Card values, the most valuable cards, and an AI grade estimate for the copy in your hand. Released April 8, 2016.
302cards in the set
April 8, 2016released
$14.02top card, Eerie Interlude
0cards at $100 or more
SOIExpansion set
Got a card from 2016 Magic Shadows over Innistrad?
Scan a card from this setScan it. The app names the card on the spot, and members get its grade estimate, its value, and whether it is worth sending to PSA or Beckett.
Most valuable 2016 Magic Shadows over Innistrad cards
| # | Card | Rarity | Market |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | Eerie InterludeFoil | Rare | $14.02 |
| 131 | Relentless DeadFoil | Mythic | $13.58 |
| 200 | Cryptolith RiteNormal | Rare | $11.74 |
| 251 | Sorin, Grim NemesisFoil | Mythic | $10.55 |
| 5 | Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the PurifierFoil | Mythic | $9.80 |
| 225 | Sage of Ancient Lore // Werewolf of Ancient HungerFoil | Rare | $7.79 |
| 107 | Diregraf ColossusFoil | Rare | $7.56 |
| 69 | Jace, Unraveler of SecretsFoil | Mythic | $7.50 |
| 32 | Open the ArmoryFoil | Uncommon | $7.31 |
| 281 | Westvale Abbey // Ormendahl, Profane PrinceFoil | Rare | $6.08 |
| 98 | Alms of the VeinFoil | Common | $5.75 |
| 245 | The Gitrog MonsterFoil | Mythic | $5.72 |
| 61 | Essence FluxFoil | Uncommon | $5.39 |
| 101 | Behold the BeyondFoil | Mythic | $5.26 |
| 242 | Anguished UnmakingFoil | Rare | $5.23 |
| 100 | Behind the ScenesFoil | Uncommon | $5.05 |
| 247 | Nahiri, the HarbingerFoil | Mythic | $4.99 |
| 227 | Second HarvestNormal | Rare | $4.57 |
| 235 | Ulvenwald HydraFoil | Mythic | $4.57 |
| 250 | Sigarda, Heron's GraceFoil | Mythic | $4.44 |
| 248 | Olivia, Mobilized for WarFoil | Mythic | $4.40 |
| 244 | Fevered VisionsFoil | Rare | $4.06 |
| 43 | Thalia's LieutenantFoil | Rare | $3.89 |
| 226 | Seasons PastFoil | Mythic | $3.44 |
| 184 | Stensia MasqueradeFoil | Uncommon | $3.39 |
TCGplayer prices via Scryfall, updated October 26, 2026. Raw, ungraded, the highest-priced finish of each card. A market price, not a sale.
Is it worth grading?
No card in 2016 Magic Shadows over Innistrad lists at $30 or more raw on TCGplayer right now. Grading at PSA runs about $25 to $30 a card once shipping and insurance both ways are counted, so for this set a grade usually costs more than it adds, unless your copy is a true 10 of the top card.
What the scanner checks on your copy
CenteringBorder widths front and back, measured the way a grader reads them.
CornersWhitening, dings and soft tips, corner by corner.
EdgesChipping and wear along all four sides.
SurfaceScratches, print lines, dents and gloss, including holo surfaces.
The grade is an AI estimate to help you decide, never an official grade. The app also flags reprint and counterfeit red flags.
2016 Magic Shadows over Innistrad checklist
1Always Watching Rare
2Angel of Deliverance Rare
5Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier Mythic
8Bygone Bishop Rare
9Cathar's Companion Common
10Chaplain's Blessing Common
12Declaration in Stone Rare
13Descend upon the Sinful Mythic
14Devilthorn Fox Common
15Drogskol Cavalry Rare
16Eerie Interlude Rare
20Gryff's Boon Uncommon
21Hanweir Militia Captain // Westvale Cult Leader Rare
22Hope Against Hope Uncommon
28Nahiri's Machinations Uncommon
29Nearheath Chaplain Uncommon
30Not Forgotten Uncommon
31Odric, Lunarch Marshal Rare
32Open the Armory Uncommon
34Pious Evangel // Wayward Disciple Uncommon
36Reaper of Flight Moonsilver Uncommon
43Thalia's Lieutenant Rare
44Thraben Inspector Common
45Topplegeist Uncommon
50Broken Concentration Uncommon
53Confirm Suspicions Rare
58Engulf the Shore Rare
59Epiphany at the Drownyard Rare
60Erdwal Illuminator Uncommon
61Essence Flux Uncommon
63Forgotten Creation Rare
65Geralf's Masterpiece Mythic
66Ghostly Wings Common
67Gone Missing Common
68Invasive Surgery Uncommon
69Jace, Unraveler of Secrets Mythic
70Jace's Scrutiny Common
71Just the Wind Common
72Lamplighter of Selhoff Common
73Manic Scribe Uncommon
75Nephalia Moondrakes Rare
77Ongoing Investigation Uncommon
78Pieces of the Puzzle Common
79Pore Over the Pages Uncommon
81Rattlechains Rare
83Rise from the Tides Uncommon
88Startled Awake // Persistent Nightmare Mythic
89Stitched Mangler Common
92Thing in the Ice // Awoken Horror Rare
93Trail of Evidence Uncommon
96Welcome to the Fold Rare
97Accursed Witch // Infectious Curse Uncommon
98Alms of the Vein Common
99Asylum Visitor Rare
100Behind the Scenes Uncommon
101Behold the Beyond Mythic
102Biting Rain Uncommon
103Call the Bloodline Uncommon
104Creeping Dread Uncommon
107Diregraf Colossus Rare
108Elusive Tormentor // Insidious Mist Rare
109Ever After Rare
111From Under the Floorboards Rare
114Gisa's Bidding Uncommon
115Grotesque Mutation Common
116Heir of Falkenrath // Heir to the Night Uncommon
118Indulgent Aristocrat Uncommon
119Kindly Stranger // Demon-Possessed Witch Uncommon
120Liliana's Indignation Uncommon
121Macabre Waltz Common
122Markov Dreadknight Rare
124Mindwrack Demon Mythic
126Murderous Compulsion Common
127Olivia's Bloodsworn Uncommon
130Rancid Rats Common
131Relentless Dead Mythic
134Shamble Back Common
139To the Slaughter Rare
141Triskaidekaphobia Rare
145Avacyn's Judgment Rare
147Breakneck Rider // Neck Breaker Uncommon
148Burn from Within Rare
150Dance with Devils Uncommon
151Devils' Playground Rare
155Falkenrath Gorger Rare
156Fiery Temper Common
157Flameblade Angel Rare
159Geier Reach Bandit // Vildin-Pack Alpha Rare
160Geistblast Uncommon
161Gibbering Fiend Uncommon
162Goldnight Castigator Mythic
163Harness the Storm Rare
166Incorrigible Youths Uncommon
168Insolent Neonate Common
169Kessig Forgemaster // Flameheart Werewolf Uncommon
170Lightning Axe Uncommon
173Malevolent Whispers Uncommon
177Rush of Adrenaline Common
179Scourge Wolf Rare
181Sin Prodder Rare
184Stensia Masquerade Uncommon
185Structural Distortion Common
188Uncaged Fury Common
189Vessel of Volatility Common
192Wolf of Devil's Breach Mythic
194Autumnal Gloom // Ancient of the Equinox Uncommon
195Briarbridge Patrol Uncommon
197Clip Wings Common
199Crawling Sensation Uncommon
200Cryptolith Rite Rare
201Cult of the Waxing Moon Uncommon
202Deathcap Cultivator Rare
203Duskwatch Recruiter // Krallenhorde Howler Uncommon
206Gloomwidow Uncommon
209Hermit of the Natterknolls // Lone Wolf of the Natterknolls Uncommon
211Howlpack Resurgence Uncommon
212Inexorable Blob Rare
214Kessig Dire Swine Common
215Lambholt Pacifist // Lambholt Butcher Uncommon
217Might Beyond Reason Common
219Moonlight Hunt Uncommon
220Obsessive Skinner Uncommon
225Sage of Ancient Lore // Werewolf of Ancient Hunger Rare
226Seasons Past Mythic
227Second Harvest Rare
228Silverfur Partisan Rare
230Soul Swallower Rare
233Tireless Tracker Rare
234Traverse the Ulvenwald Rare
235Ulvenwald Hydra Mythic
237Vessel of Nascency Common
240Weirding Wood Uncommon
241Altered Ego Rare
242Anguished Unmaking Rare
243Arlinn Kord // Arlinn, Embraced by the Moon Mythic
244Fevered Visions Rare
245The Gitrog Monster Mythic
246Invocation of Saint Traft Rare
247Nahiri, the Harbinger Mythic
248Olivia, Mobilized for War Mythic
249Prized Amalgam Rare
250Sigarda, Heron's Grace Mythic
251Sorin, Grim Nemesis Mythic
252Brain in a Jar Rare
253Corrupted Grafstone Rare
256Harvest Hand // Scrounged Scythe Uncommon
257Haunted Cloak Uncommon
259Murderer's Axe Uncommon
260Neglected Heirloom // Ashmouth Blade Uncommon
262Shard of Broken Glass Common
263Skeleton Key Uncommon
264Slayer's Plate Rare
265Tamiyo's Journal Rare
269Wild-Field Scarecrow Uncommon
270Choked Estuary Rare
271Drownyard Temple Rare
272Foreboding Ruins Rare
273Forsaken Sanctuary Uncommon
274Fortified Village Rare
275Foul Orchard Uncommon
276Game Trail Rare
277Highland Lake Uncommon
278Port Town Rare
279Stone Quarry Uncommon
280Warped Landscape Common
281Westvale Abbey // Ormendahl, Profane Prince Rare
282Woodland Stream Uncommon
285Plains Common
286Island Common
289Swamp Common
290Swamp Common
291Swamp Common
293Mountain Common
294Mountain Common
295Forest Common
Showing the 175 most valuable of the 302 cards in the set.
Scan one and see
Scan a card from this setSee what your card is in seconds. Its grade, its value and your whole collection come with a Treasury Membership.
More Magic: The Gathering sets
Kaladesh2016 · 278 cards · KLDConspiracy: Take the Crown2016 · 222 cards · CN2Eldritch Moon2016 · 208 cards · EMNEternal Masters2016 · 249 cards · EMAOath of the Gatewatch2016 · 187 cards · OGWCommander 20152015 · 342 cards · C15Battle for Zendikar2015 · 299 cards · BFZMagic Origins2015 · 288 cards · ORI