THE HOBBY 2023 Magic Tales of Middle-earth Commander
Card values, the most valuable cards, and a free AI grade estimate for the copy in your hand. Released June 23, 2023.
591cards in the set
June 23, 2023released
$10,000top card, Cavern of Souls
27cards at $100 or more
LTCCommander set
Got a card from 2023 Magic Tales of Middle-earth Commander?
Scan a card from this setScan it free. The app identifies the card, estimates its grade, and tells you whether it is worth sending to PSA or Beckett.
Most valuable 2023 Magic Tales of Middle-earth Commander cards
| # | Card | Rarity | Market |
|---|---|---|---|
| 392z | Cavern of SoulsFoil | Mythic | $10,000 |
| 404z | Shinka, the Bloodsoaked KeepFoil | Mythic | $3,300 |
| 384z | Sword of Hearth and HomeFoil | Mythic | $3,000 |
| 409z | Sol RingFoil | Mythic | $2,750 |
| 397z | KarakasFoil | Mythic | $2,700 |
| 395z | Homeward PathFoil | Mythic | $2,500 |
| 391z | Castle ArdenvaleFoil | Mythic | $2,200 |
| 408 | Sol RingNormal | Mythic | $1,718 |
| 402z | Pillar of the ParunsFoil | Mythic | $750 |
| 409 | Sol RingNormal | Mythic | $597 |
| 410 | Sol RingNormal | Mythic | $463 |
| 387 | Ancient TombFoil | Mythic | $441 |
| 405 | Urborg, Tomb of YawgmothFoil | Mythic | $321 |
| 394 | Gemstone CavernsFoil | Mythic | $305 |
| 392 | Cavern of SoulsFoil | Mythic | $225 |
| 378 | The Great HengeFoil | Mythic | $212 |
| 383 | ShadowspearFoil | Mythic | $206 |
| 357 | Ancient TombFoil | Mythic | $196 |
| 407 | Yavimaya, Cradle of GrowthFoil | Mythic | $182 |
| 381 | The OzolithFoil | Mythic | $180 |
| 399 | Minamo, School at Water's EdgeFoil | Mythic | $161 |
| 390 | Cabal CoffersFoil | Mythic | $155 |
| 375 | Urborg, Tomb of YawgmothFoil | Mythic | $133 |
| 526 | Diabolic IntentFoil | Mythic | $126 |
| 523 | Pact of NegationFoil | Rare | $122 |
TCGplayer prices via Scryfall, updated September 10, 2026. Raw, ungraded, the highest-priced finish of each card. A market price, not a sale.
Is it worth grading?
75 cards in 2023 Magic Tales of Middle-earth Commander list at $30 or more raw on TCGplayer. Grading at PSA runs about $25 to $30 a card once shipping and insurance both ways are counted, so those 75 are the cards where a high grade can pay for itself. For the rest, a grade usually costs more than it adds.
The deciding question is condition, and that is what the scanner reads: photograph the front and back and The Hobby Treasury scores centering, corners, edges and surface, gives a PSA-style estimate, and makes the worth-submitting call before you pay a fee.
What the scanner checks on your copy
CenteringBorder widths front and back, measured the way a grader reads them.
CornersWhitening, dings and soft tips, corner by corner.
EdgesChipping and wear along all four sides.
SurfaceScratches, print lines, dents and gloss, including holo surfaces.
The grade is an AI estimate to help you decide, never an official grade. The app also flags reprint and counterfeit red flags.
2023 Magic Tales of Middle-earth Commander checklist
12The Gaffer Rare
23Raise the Palisade Rare
31Cavern-Hoard Dragon Rare
32Gimli of the Glittering Caves Rare
38Galadhrim Ambush Rare
79Relic of Sauron Rare
80The Black Gate Rare
96The Gaffer Rare
106Raise the Palisade Rare
114Cavern-Hoard Dragon Rare
115Gimli of the Glittering Caves Rare
118Arwen, Weaver of Hope Rare
121Galadhrim Ambush Rare
139Forth Eorlingas! Rare
140Gríma, Saruman's Footman Rare
142Lord of the Nazgûl Rare
151Taunt from the Rampart Rare
153Treebeard, Gracious Host Rare
159Relic of Sauron Rare
160The Black Gate Rare
197Swan Song Rare
203Living Death Rare
206Reanimate Rare
208Sanguine Bond Rare
209Toxic Deluge Rare
233Asceticism Rare
235Birds of Paradise Rare
242Essence Warden Common
249Heroic Intervention Rare
274Basalt Monolith Uncommon
277Door of Destinies Rare
280Herald's Horn Uncommon
289Vanquisher's Banner Rare
348The Great Henge Mythic
349Cloudstone Curio Mythic
350Ensnaring Bridge Mythic
351The Ozolith Mythic
352Rings of Brighthearth Mythic
353Shadowspear Mythic
354Sword of Hearth and Home Mythic
355Sword of the Animist Mythic
357Ancient Tomb Mythic
358Bojuka Bog Mythic
359Boseiju, Who Shelters All Mythic
360Cabal Coffers Mythic
361Castle Ardenvale Mythic
362Cavern of Souls Mythic
363Deserted Temple Mythic
364Gemstone Caverns Mythic
365Homeward Path Mythic
366Horizon Canopy Mythic
367Karakas Mythic
368Kor Haven Mythic
369Minamo, School at Water's Edge Mythic
371Oboro, Palace in the Clouds Mythic
372Pillar of the Paruns Mythic
373Reflecting Pool Mythic
374Shinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep Mythic
375Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth Mythic
376Wasteland Mythic
377Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth Mythic
378The Great Henge Mythic
379Cloudstone Curio Mythic
380Ensnaring Bridge Mythic
381The Ozolith Mythic
382Rings of Brighthearth Mythic
383Shadowspear Mythic
384Sword of Hearth and Home Mythic
384zSword of Hearth and Home Mythic
385Sword of the Animist Mythic
386Thorn of Amethyst Mythic
387Ancient Tomb Mythic
388Bojuka Bog Mythic
389Boseiju, Who Shelters All Mythic
390Cabal Coffers Mythic
391Castle Ardenvale Mythic
391zCastle Ardenvale Mythic
392Cavern of Souls Mythic
392zCavern of Souls Mythic
393Deserted Temple Mythic
394Gemstone Caverns Mythic
395Homeward Path Mythic
395zHomeward Path Mythic
396Horizon Canopy Mythic
397Karakas Mythic
397zKarakas Mythic
398Kor Haven Mythic
399Minamo, School at Water's Edge Mythic
400Mouth of Ronom Mythic
401Oboro, Palace in the Clouds Mythic
402Pillar of the Paruns Mythic
402zPillar of the Paruns Mythic
403Reflecting Pool Mythic
404Shinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep Mythic
404zShinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep Mythic
405Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth Mythic
406Wasteland Mythic
407Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth Mythic
408Sol Ring Mythic
409Sol Ring Mythic
409zSol Ring Mythic
410Sol Ring Mythic
414The Gaffer Rare
419Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit Rare
425Raise the Palisade Rare
431Shelob, Dread Weaver Rare
433Cavern-Hoard Dragon Rare
434Gimli of the Glittering Caves Rare
437Arwen, Weaver of Hope Rare
440Galadhrim Ambush Rare
448Aragorn, King of Gondor Mythic
449The Balrog of Moria Rare
456Éowyn, Shieldmaiden Mythic
459Farmer Cotton Rare
460Forth Eorlingas! Rare
461Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit Mythic
464Gríma, Saruman's Footman Rare
465In the Darkness Bind Them Rare
467Lord of the Nazgûl Rare
472Pippin, Warden of Isengard Rare
476Sam, Loyal Attendant Mythic
477Saruman, the White Hand Mythic
478Sauron, Lord of the Rings Mythic
481Taunt from the Rampart Rare
483Treebeard, Gracious Host Rare
485Crown of Gondor Rare
489Relic of Sauron Rare
490The Black Gate Rare
491Andúril, Narsil Reforged Rare
493Legolas's Quick Reflexes Rare
494Gimli's Reckless Might Rare
498Galadriel, Light of Valinor Mythic
500Galadriel's Dismissal Rare
502Galadhrim Brigade Rare
503Olórin's Searing Light Rare
505Rammas Echor, Ancient Shield Rare
507Gandalf of the Secret Fire Mythic
509Call Forth the Tempest Rare
510Nazgûl Battle-Mace Rare
514Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress Rare
515Kenrith, the Returned King Mythic
516Ishkanah, Grafwidow Mythic
517Doran, the Siege Tower Rare
518Hammerheim Rare
519Urborg Rare
520Soul's Attendant Uncommon
521Stonehewer Giant Rare
522Worship Rare
523Pact of Negation Rare
524River Kelpie Rare
525Abyssal Persecutor Mythic
526Diabolic Intent Mythic
527Elvish Harbinger Uncommon
529Seasons Past Rare
530Second Harvest Rare
531Sylvan Tutor Mythic
532Tempt with Discovery Uncommon
533Timber Protector Rare
535Andúril, Narsil Reforged Rare
536Aragorn, Hornburg Hero Mythic
537Legolas's Quick Reflexes Rare
538Gimli's Reckless Might Rare
539Isengard Unleashed Rare
542Galadriel, Light of Valinor Mythic
544Galadriel's Dismissal Rare
545Mists of Lórien Rare
546Galadhrim Brigade Rare
547Olórin's Searing Light Rare
549Rammas Echor, Ancient Shield Rare
551Gandalf of the Secret Fire Mythic
553Call Forth the Tempest Rare
554Nazgûl Battle-Mace Rare
555Witch-king, Sky Scourge Mythic
557Fell Beast of Mordor Rare
558Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress Rare
Showing the 175 most valuable of the 591 cards in the set.
Scan one and see
Scan a card from this setFree unlimited scanning. Save your collection, grades and values with a Treasury Membership.
More Magic: The Gathering sets
Doctor Who2023 · 1178 cards · WHOWilds of Eldraine Commander2023 · 173 cards · WOCWilds of Eldraine2023 · 381 cards · WOECommander Masters2023 · 1067 cards · CMMThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth2023 · 856 cards · LTRMarch of the Machine: The Aftermath2023 · 230 cards · MATMarch of the Machine2023 · 387 cards · MOMMarch of the Machine Commander2023 · 450 cards · MOC