THE HOBBY TREASURY Scan a card free

2023 Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth

Card values, the most valuable cards, and a free AI grade estimate for the copy in your hand. Released June 23, 2023.

856cards in the set
June 23, 2023released
$8,000top card, Aragorn, the Uniter
39cards at $100 or more
LTRDraft innovation set
Got a card from 2023 Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth?

Scan it free. The app identifies the card, estimates its grade, and tells you whether it is worth sending to PSA or Beckett.

Scan a card from this set

Most valuable 2023 Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth cards

#CardRarityMarket
741zAragorn, the UniterFoilMythic$8,000
299Gandalf the WhiteNormalMythic$3,000
749zPalantír of OrthancFoilMythic$3,000
748The One RingFoilMythic$1,713
744Sauron, the Dark LordFoilMythic$825
697The One RingFoilMythic$692
732Gandalf the WhiteFoilMythic$500
750Mount DoomFoilMythic$430
745Tom BombadilFoilMythic$411
749Palantír of OrthancFoilMythic$356
380The One RingFoilMythic$352
736Witch-king of AngmarFoilMythic$322
791The One RingFoilMythic$286
739Last March of the EntsFoilMythic$251
743Saruman of Many ColorsFoilMythic$250
723NazgûlFoilUncommon$247
741Aragorn, the UniterFoilMythic$228
747GlamdringFoilMythic$199
726NazgûlFoilUncommon$189
740Radagast the BrownFoilMythic$188
551NazgûlFoilUncommon$182
554Orcish BowmastersFoilRare$181
821Sauron, the Dark LordFoilMythic$181
675Sauron, the Dark LordFoilMythic$175
728NazgûlFoilUncommon$173

TCGplayer prices via Scryfall, updated September 10, 2026. Raw, ungraded, the highest-priced finish of each card. A market price, not a sale.

Is it worth grading?

81 cards in 2023 Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth list at $30 or more raw on TCGplayer. Grading at PSA runs about $25 to $30 a card once shipping and insurance both ways are counted, so those 81 are the cards where a high grade can pay for itself. For the rest, a grade usually costs more than it adds.

The deciding question is condition, and that is what the scanner reads: photograph the front and back and The Hobby Treasury scores centering, corners, edges and surface, gives a PSA-style estimate, and makes the worth-submitting call before you pay a fee.

What the scanner checks on your copy

CenteringBorder widths front and back, measured the way a grader reads them.
CornersWhitening, dings and soft tips, corner by corner.
EdgesChipping and wear along all four sides.
SurfaceScratches, print lines, dents and gloss, including holo surfaces.

The grade is an AI estimate to help you decide, never an official grade. The app also flags reprint and counterfeit red flags.

2023 Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth checklist

4Boromir, Warden of the Tower Rare
15Flowering of the White Tree Rare
19Gandalf the White Mythic
100Nazgûl Uncommon
103Orcish Bowmasters Rare
114Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
149Spiteful Banditry Mythic
151There and Back Again Rare
158Delighted Halfling Rare
172Last March of the Ents Mythic
193Arwen, Mortal Queen Mythic
213Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff Rare
224Sauron, the Dark Lord Mythic
245Mithril Coat Rare
246The One Ring Mythic
247Palantír of Orthanc Mythic
256Minas Tirith Rare
258Mount Doom Mythic
287Aragorn and Arwen, Wed Mythic
288Sauron, the Lidless Eye Mythic
293Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin Rare
296Galadriel, Gift-Giver Rare
298Bilbo's Ring Rare
299Gandalf the White Mythic
300Saruman of Many Colors Mythic
305Gandalf the White Mythic
311Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
317Aragorn, the Uniter Mythic
329Sauron, the Dark Lord Mythic
332Nazgûl Uncommon
333Nazgûl Uncommon
334Nazgûl Uncommon
335Nazgûl Uncommon
336Nazgûl Uncommon
337Nazgûl Uncommon
338Nazgûl Uncommon
339Nazgûl Uncommon
341Minas Tirith Rare
343Mount Doom Mythic
348Flowering of the White Tree Rare
360Glóin, Dwarf Emissary Rare
363Delighted Halfling Rare
367Arwen, Mortal Queen Mythic
370Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff Rare
379Mithril Coat Rare
380The One Ring Mythic
381Palantír of Orthanc Mythic
385Ringwraiths Rare
387Elanor Gardner Rare
391Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin Rare
393Galadriel, Gift-Giver Rare
394Aragorn and Arwen, Wed Mythic
396Sauron, the Lidless Eye Mythic
397Bilbo's Ring Rare
402Delighted Halfling Rare
407Boromir, Warden of the Tower Rare
412Saruman of Many Colors Mythic
418Last March of the Ents Mythic
420Minas Tirith Rare
423Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
433Orcish Bowmasters Rare
434Aragorn, the Uniter Mythic
439Spiteful Banditry Mythic
442Gandalf the White Mythic
451The One Ring Mythic
453The Battle of Bywater Rare
455Boromir, Warden of the Tower Rare
456Dawn of a New Age Mythic
466Flowering of the White Tree Rare
468Forge Anew Rare
470Gandalf the White Mythic
495Borne Upon a Wind Rare
511Lórien Revealed Common
523Storm of Saruman Mythic
526The Watcher in the Water Mythic
530Call of the Ring Rare
551Nazgûl Uncommon
553One Ring to Rule Them All Rare
554Orcish Bowmasters Rare
558Shadow of the Enemy Mythic
565Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
583Glóin, Dwarf Emissary Rare
600Spiteful Banditry Mythic
602There and Back Again Rare
609Delighted Halfling Rare
611Elven Chorus Rare
614Entish Restoration Uncommon
620Generous Ent Common
623Last March of the Ents Mythic
643Aragorn, the Uniter Mythic
644Arwen, Mortal Queen Mythic
654Flame of Anor Rare
664Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff Rare
673Samwise Gamgee Rare
674Saruman of Many Colors Mythic
675Sauron, the Dark Lord Mythic
681Shelob, Child of Ungoliant Rare
685Tom Bombadil Mythic
687Andúril, Flame of the West Mythic
690Glamdring Mythic
694Lembas Common
696Mithril Coat Rare
697The One Ring Mythic
698Palantír of Orthanc Mythic
701Sting, the Glinting Dagger Rare
707Minas Tirith Rare
709Mount Doom Mythic
723Nazgûl Uncommon
724Nazgûl Uncommon
725Nazgûl Uncommon
726Nazgûl Uncommon
727Nazgûl Uncommon
728Nazgûl Uncommon
729Nazgûl Uncommon
730Nazgûl Uncommon
731Dawn of a New Age Mythic
732Gandalf the White Mythic
733Storm of Saruman Mythic
734The Watcher in the Water Mythic
735Shadow of the Enemy Mythic
736Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
737Hew the Entwood Mythic
738Spiteful Banditry Mythic
739Last March of the Ents Mythic
740Radagast the Brown Mythic
741Aragorn, the Uniter Mythic
741zAragorn, the Uniter Mythic
742Arwen, Mortal Queen Mythic
743Saruman of Many Colors Mythic
744Sauron, the Dark Lord Mythic
745Tom Bombadil Mythic
746Andúril, Flame of the West Mythic
747Glamdring Mythic
748The One Ring Mythic
749Palantír of Orthanc Mythic
749zPalantír of Orthanc Mythic
750Mount Doom Mythic
751Barad-dûr Rare
752Minas Tirith Rare
753Mines of Moria Rare
754Mount Doom Mythic
755Rivendell Rare
756The Shire Rare
759Flowering of the White Tree Rare
761Borne Upon a Wind Rare
766Call of the Ring Rare
771Glóin, Dwarf Emissary Rare
774Delighted Halfling Rare
778Arwen, Mortal Queen Mythic
781Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff Rare
786Andúril, Flame of the West Mythic
790Mithril Coat Rare
791The One Ring Mythic
792Palantír of Orthanc Mythic
794Boromir, Warden of the Tower Rare
796Frodo, Sauron's Bane Rare
797Gandalf the White Mythic
802Sauron, the Necromancer Rare
803Witch-king of Angmar Mythic
805Legolas, Master Archer Rare
809Aragorn, the Uniter Mythic
811Faramir, Prince of Ithilien Rare
813Galadriel of Lothlórien Rare
814Gandalf the Grey Rare
817Merry, Esquire of Rohan Rare
818Pippin, Guard of the Citadel Rare
819Samwise Gamgee Rare
820Saruman of Many Colors Mythic
821Sauron, the Dark Lord Mythic
822Sméagol, Helpful Guide Rare
823Tom Bombadil Mythic
826Warg Rider Rare
827Riders of the Mark Rare
831Warg Rider Rare
832Riders of the Mark Rare

Showing the 175 most valuable of the 856 cards in the set.

Scan one and see

Free unlimited scanning. Save your collection, grades and values with a Treasury Membership.

Scan a card from this set

More Magic: The Gathering sets

Wilds of Eldraine Commander2023 · 173 cards · WOCWilds of Eldraine2023 · 381 cards · WOECommander Masters2023 · 1067 cards · CMMTales of Middle-earth Commander2023 · 591 cards · LTCMarch of the Machine: The Aftermath2023 · 230 cards · MATMarch of the Machine2023 · 387 cards · MOMMarch of the Machine Commander2023 · 450 cards · MOCPhyrexia: All Will Be One2023 · 479 cards · ONE